The SSH host key has changed on 8 April, 2022 to this one: SHA256:573uTBSeh74kvOo0HJXi5ijdzRm8me27suzNEDlGyrQ

Write a review about the Keyboardio Model 100

master
Gergely Polonkai 2 months ago
parent 051fd87fb5
commit b10a42866f
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: 2D2885533B869ED4
  1. 306
      content/blog/keyboardio-model100-review.rst
  2. BIN
      content/images/desk-photo.png
  3. 26
      my_theme/static/css/main.css

@ -0,0 +1,306 @@
Keyboardio’s Model 100 keyboard – a review
##########################################
:date: 2022-06-18T03:02Z
:category: blog
:tags: review,keyboard
:url: blog/keyboardio-model100-keyboard-review/
:save_as: blog/keyboardio-model100-keyboard-review/index.html
:status: published
:author: Gergely Polonkai
TL;DR: despite the fact that i almost have to re-learn typing, this thing is awesome and i think
everyone typing a decent amount of letters a day should get a split, or even a split+vertical
keyboard.
-----
I’m not a keyboard enthusiast, but i heard so much about split keyboards and `Keyboardio
<https://shop.keyboard.io>`_’s Model 01 before that i decided to back their `Model 100 on
Kickstarter <https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/keyboardio/model-100>`_ about a year ago. It’s
super expensive in my book (about 20% of my monthly salary when i ordered it) but since they
announced the project way before the KS campaign i had time to slowly put aside some money every
month. This makes it the first electronic device that i actually wanted so much (and probably
needed; ergonomics is important, as i learned the hard way coming closer to 40) that i put aside
money for it. Their hunt-and-pecking chicken in the promotion video was also pretty convincing.
We got a lot of info on what is happening during the time between backing and delivery.
Some video footage of how the keyboards are made, from production to QA, was one of them, and it
looked really awesome. Even though i only gave my money, the whole project felt more personal
this way.
They had a lot of delay in production due to various reasons (COVID and Chinese new year being the
biggest among them) but when i finally got a mail that said
your early-delivery Model 100 is due to be ready to ship out this week. I’m writing today to
confirm your shipping address. We’ll send you another email with tracking information as soon as
your keyboard ships out.
i was super excited about it and couldn’t wait for it to arrive.
Shipping was handled by FedEx; they did duty handling and delivery quick and with great care.
This post is not their review, but they surely deserve a shout-out. My package even arrived one
day before they originally promised.
And now, finally onto the review itself! Keep in mind that things below are not in order of
importance but more like in the order of how i discovered them.
The package
===========
I really don’t like unboxing videos; i just find them boring. For this keyboard i tried to make
one, but quickly dumped the idea. Then i tried to make pictures of the steps, but still no luck:
i got two photos of the early steps (opening the first box) than i gave up. So if you are here
for unboxing material, you should close the page now.
The package contained two black boxes. They look really cool, with the Keyboardio logo on them.
The smaller box contains the stands (which have a standard tripod screw, so you can technically
put your keyboard halves on camera tripods next to your desk, if that’s your game). The bigger
box contained nothing but a travelling case. It’s pretty sturdy, covered with black textile, and
with a bumpy logo. The keyboard has travelled all the way from China in that case; travelling
case redefined.
Inside the case were the two keyboard halves, a USB-C to USB-A cable, two RJ45 cables (a short one
when you use the keyboard as one piece, and a long one if you want to use it split), a key switch
puller (because if you don’t like your switches, you can switch to different switches; i’ll show
myself out), two pieces of plastic to hold the two halves together in a linear or a rooftop shape,
and a screwdriver. Because your warranty is not void if you take the keyboard apart. Because why
should it be?
Assembling the keyboard, especially in a split fashion, is not a big deal, just connect one of the
RJ45 cables to both halves, then use the USB-C cable to connect the left half to your computer,
and you are good to go.
The Look
========
This thing has got the look; it is beautiful! The folks at Keyboardio didn’t name it “heirloom
keyboard” for nothing. When i ordered it i had a green desk so i chose the walnut case, which is
a darker shade of brown. Since then i switched to a new desk i got from my brother-in-law, which is
also dark brown (although slightly darker then the keyboard’s enclosure), so i’m probably up to
painting or re-foiling my desk soon. Still, it looks good on my desk, even if it doesn’t
stand out.
My new(ish) desk has a drawer-like thingy for the keyboard, but its height is designed to hold a
traditional keyboard; for the Model 100 on its stands it’s not high enough; plus it’s about 15cm
below the desk itself which is too low for my height. On the desk i already had an XP-PEN tablet
so the Model 100 got placed next to it in a split fashion, on both sides. I had to drill two
holes in the desk for the RJ45 cable so it doesn’t take unnecessary space, but it’s a worthy
compromise.
.. figure:: {static}../images/desk-photo.png
:alt: Photo of my desk, a dark brown computer desk with a monitor stand and a separate monitor
next to it.
This is my current setup: a tablet with wings! And a messy table. And a `rubber duck
<https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rubber_duck_debugging>`_. And a rubber shark for tougher
problems. And some retro-computing.
The Feel
========
With the adjustable stands it’s really comfortable. It took me a few tries, but now that it’s
done my hands never felt this good on a keyboard before. It’s worth noting that i’m typing
extensively on traditional keyboards since my early teens, so my arms developed a little different
(my radius bones are slightly longer than they should be). I didn’t even have those V-shaped,
so-called ergonomic ones, although i yearned for one. Some consequences of this are that my hands
don’t feel distorted at all when i use traditional keyboards, stuff designed to be ergonomic for
the general public might not be comfortable for me immediately, and typing on a split/ortholinear
keyboard is totally new ground for me because for me *this* is distorted (a bit).
Holding your fingers on this keyboard is slightly different from traditional ones as you don’t
have to keep them on a straight line, but the curve of the home row actually follows the curve of
your fingers. You know those little bumps on the :kbd:`F` and :kbd:`J` keys? In case you don’t
know, they are there to help you position your hands on the “home row” for touch typing (maybe the
reason they call it touch typing instead of blind typing?); you have to find them with your index
fingers, and you’re all set. Now, since you hold your hands a bit different on the Model 100,
they didn’t only add this bump to the usual :kbd:`F` / :kbd:`J` keys, they are also present on
:kbd:`A` and :kbd:`;` so you can easily position your pinkies, too. Really thoughtful design!
Typing on it after using traditional keyboards for all these years is… different, to say the
least. It took me some time to get up to *a* typing speed (ie. not hunt-and-pecking; heck, typing
my 14 characters long desktop password took 3 tries for the first time) and it was clear that it
should probably take days, if not weeks, to get up to my original speed. It’s a completely
different experience and calls for lots of learning and maybe a layout change, too. For the
record i use a Dvorak inspired layout for several years now; on this keyboard the letters are more
or less where they should be, but some symbols are not that comfortable to reach than they were on
my old one. A lot of non-letter keys are at different places: reaching for the top right for
backspace and top left for escape was an issue for a while, but it’s almost completely gone now.
It’s funny, though, that the keys arranged in this ortholinear fashion didn’t make my head spin
too much. I did reach to the side a bit sometimes, but i got lost of that habit after only two
days.
The learning process
====================
Even though the designers `suggest <https://shop.keyboard.io/pages/model100>`_ to start using
split keyboards gradually (start with 15ish minutes in the morning and increase your usage every
day) i used it almost exclusively for my first full workday. We had a short emergency at my $job
for which i used my old keyboard because of speed, but other than that i used the Model 100. What
can i say? I’m a rebel. Also, this method worked really good for me when `i switched to Dvorak
<{filename}2013-03-13-dvorak-and-me.rst>`_, so i guessed it will be fine for split keyboards, too.
Even after a day my typing speed was still far from my old one, but it got better every hour. I
still occasionally pressed Num Lock when i wanted to Backspace (Backspace is under your left
thumb on the default layout) and i often pressed Backspace when i wanted Space (Space is under
your right thumb). Enter being to the left of my right index instead of being to the right of my
right pinky was also confusing sometimes. I probably haven’t looked at my keyboard this much for,
i don’t know… 20 years? But i was slowly getting rid of hunt-and-pecking which was a win in my
book.
After more than a week the keyboard felt really good. I was already pretty close to my original
typing speed which wasn’t super fast, but decent enough to amaze some non-techie persons.
Technicalities
==============
This section is specific to `Kaleidoscope <https://kaleidoscope.readthedocs.io/>`_, the factory
firmware of the Model 100. If you want to use a different firmware (i guess you could, but don’t
ask me how), just skip ahead.
Early delivery keyboards arrived with QWERTY keycaps and a default firmware, both holding some
strange things.
Left half
---------
First, there is a :kbd:`prog` key at the top left corner. It is used by the keyboard’s boot
loader to enter programming mode (ie. firmware upgrade), but otherwise it can be used as any other
key (more on that later).
There’s also a :kbd:`led` key, which sounded strange, but who knows… after giving it a few pushes
it turned out that it was switching between different LED modes, of which there are plenty from a
rainbow wave to dull single colour backlight.
:kbd:`Esc` moved to the bottom right of the left half is also strange, but i guess there’s a
reason for that.
:kbd:`Page Up` and :kbd:`Page Down` living on the leftmost column was also a big surprise and, as
time showed, a real waste of precious keys for me as a hardly ever use those.
Right half
----------
The first surprise was that although it *does* have a logo key (with a Keyboardio butterfly on
it), it doesn’t act as one. Rather than that, it’s actually a right :kbd:`Alt`, AKA :kbd:`AltGr`
key.
On the top left there is an :kbd:`any` key. Like, a key actually labelled as ``any``. It
sends a random keystroke (showing you the power of macros).
Thumb rows
----------
Under four rows of keys (except the middle two columns which only have three keys each) are four
“thumb keys”, arranged in a way that your thumb can comfortably reach them.
On the left side, they are :kbd:`ctrl`, :kbd:`backspace`, :kbd:`cmd`, and :kbd:`shift`; on the right side they are :kbd:`shift`, :kbd:`alt`, :kbd:`space`, and :kbd:`ctrl`.
The :kbd:`cmd` key’s label is foreign to PC people but is used a lot on Macs. Turned out it’s the
:kbd:`Super` key (AKA logo, AKA Windows key).
There are also two palm keys labelled as :kbd:`fun`, which are placed so they are easy to press
with your palms, but not easy enough so that you press them all the time. By default they act a
bit like a regular notebook’s :kbd:`fn` keys, adding extra functions to most keys like media
player control, arrow keys, and mouse operations.
Layers
------
The default firmware has 5 layers: one for the basic keys (what you see printed on the keycaps), a
number pad layer, one for the extra functions (what you get by using the :kbd:`fun` keys), and two
empty ones you can use for your own dark goals (after configuring them in Chrysalys; more about
that later).
Layers don’t have a fixed order but they are stacked when you switch between them. You have a
default layer, and when you press a layer changing key another one is put on top of that. Now
when you press a key and it has a function configured, you get that function. The key can also be
transparent on that layer, so the same key’s function from the layer below (the one previously
active) will be activated. If it’s transparent on that layer, too, then the layer below that will
be taken, etc. If you hit a transparent key on the bottom layer, it acts as a blocked key. Keys
can also be configured as blocked; blocked keys don’t send anything, as if they weren’t even
there.
There are four different layer change modes:
- Layer Shift is temporary, like how the :kbd:`Shift` key works
- Locking also pushes the new layer onto the old one like shifting does, but it remains active,
like how :kbd:`Caps Lock` works
- Moving clears the whole stack and makes the target layer the default one. This is like changing
your keyboard layout in the OS
- The OneShot plugin (enabled by default) adds another method, labelled “layer shift for next
action” in Chrysalis. If you press such a key once, it will act like a layer lock for the next
single keypress. If you press it twice, it will act as a layer lock, until the OneShot effect
is cancelled (with the :kbd:`Escape` key, or with a preconfigured “OneShot cancel” key).
Pressing it once more will also disable the OneShot effect.
Mouse functions
---------------
The keyboard itself doesn’t just advertise itself as a keyboard, but a fully compliant HID, Human
Interface Device. It can also act as a mouse, except instead of moving around a piece of plastic
on your desk, you press keys. I put away my actual mouse for about 30 minutes and made myself
using the mouse functions exclusively, and i must say it’s not terrible. For the record, i don’t
use the mouse too much; mostly for gaming only. Well, for gaming you probably won’t use a
keyboard based mouse (especially not for mouse-heavy shooters), but for my desktop use case it’s
totally enough.
The most useful feature here (for me) is having a scroll wheel integrated into my keyboard. This
way i don’t have to reach for the mouse when all i want to do is scroll down a bit (for one-page
scrolling there’s still :kbd:`Space`).
Mouse movement is… not ideal. It starts very slowly and gradually increases the pointer speed to
so fast you won’t be able to follow it with your eyes. There’s also mouse warping for moving to
the different corners of your screen, but it doesn’t work well on my multi-monitor Sway setup; i
haven’t tried it on other OSes or desktop environments.
LEDs
----
I experimented with the LEDs, too. Every key has it’s own RGB LED underneath and all of them can
be customised to be lit in different colours. The firmware has a lot of modes from your average
single-colour backlight through moving rainbow gradients to more exotic ones. My favourite is
called Stalker (we agreed with the authors that it’s a pretty bad name) with the blazing trail
effect: whenever you press a key it lights up in white, then fades through red to turned off. It
looks really cool, especially since i have accumulated some actual typing speed so the LEDs don’t
have time to turn off before i press the same key again. Not the ideal one for typing passwords
in public, though. Also, if you use the ColorMap mode, you can configure a different LED layout
for any or all of your layers which can be super helpful in some cases. Unfortunately the LED
mode is global, so you can’t have different modes for different layers, unless you write a plugin
(although you can get close enough with colormap).
The Software
============
`Chrysalis <https://github.com/keyboardio/Chrysalis>`_ is a “desktop application” to configure
your Kaleidoscope based keyboard on the fly. It’s a really good one; my only problem with it is
that it’s based on Electron (ie. not a real desktop app, just a fancy web page running in a
dedicated browser), although i do understand the choice: iterating over new features is really
straightforward and fast this way without risking that one platform falls behind another.
I had some trouble making it run on my desktop (i’m using `Sway <https://swaywm.org/>`_, a Wayland
based window manager; it’s not your everyday Linux setup unless you’re a geek like me), and there
were some permission issues, too; but it all worked out fast thanks to their developer, `@algernon
<https://asylum.madhouse-project.org/about/>`_’s help (one of the software’s developers, and with
whom we share first names!)
Chrysalis has just the right amount of bells and whistles and it can fully customise every single
key (given you use the official firmware, which you don’t have to, but i really think you should,
at least until you get used to it). There are some things to grasp before you start using it
(layers being the one of them), but after that one can probably use it without much of a thought.
Closing thoughts
================
I originally wanted to write about my final setup (as of now) but it would have doubled the length
of this post, so it will have its own.
All in all, the Model 100 is a really good keyboard. I could probably have spent this money
better given that i’m a family man with kids and a house that constantly needs fixing, but i’m
happy i didn’t. If you type a lot then you should probably treat your hands with a split and/or
ortholinear keyboard. It gives a fantastic experience.
Also, given the whole thing is open source, and all the parts you need are available to buy you
can even build one at home, but if you have the money you should definitely buy it. If for
nothing else, then as a heirloom.

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1.3 MiB

@ -57,8 +57,11 @@ a:link, a:visited {
/* Paragraphs */
div.line-block,
p { margin-top: 1em;
margin-bottom: 1em;}
p {
margin-top: 1em;
margin-bottom: 1em;
text-align: justify;
}
strong, b {font-weight: bold;}
em, i {font-style: italic;}
@ -145,12 +148,21 @@ img.left, figure.left, div.figure.align-left {
}
/* .rst support */
div.figure {
width: 800px;
background-color: #ddd;
margin: 0 auto 1em -20px;
}
div.figure img, figure img { /* to fill figure exactly */
width: 100%;
}
div.figure p.caption, figure p.caption { /* margin provided by figure */
margin-top: 0;
margin-bottom: 0;
font-size: 80%;
text-align: center;
}
/*
@ -553,3 +565,13 @@ li:last-child .hentry, #content > .hentry {border: 0; margin: 0;}
tt.literal {
background-color: #eeeeee;
}
kbd {
border: 1px solid black;
padding: 2px;
display: inline-block;
border-radius: 4px;
min-width: 1em;
text-align: center;
background-color: #ddd;
}

Loading…
Cancel
Save